We’re Here To Help!


We hope you never have a claim but if you do, Paxton Insurance Agency is here to help.

Although many companies have 24/7 claim centers, there are many advantages to calling our office to report your claim. Our specialists can advise you on the ramifications of filing your claim, and explain how the claims process works – eliminating frustrations which usually arise from the unknown.

To report your loss to Paxton Insurance Agency, please call us at (850) 398-5810.

If it is after business hours and your claim needs immediate attention please call the company whose policy you own at the appropriate number listed below.

Please try to have your policy number handy before calling these toll free service numbers.

Upon completing this call, we request you also call us at the number listed above to inform us of your claim as well.

Below is a list of carriers and their claims hotline numbers:


Allied Insurance Company 866-322-3214

Allstate Insurance Company 800-255-7828

American Integrity Insurance Group 866-277-9871

American Traditions Insurance 866-270-8430

American Strategic 866-274-5677

AmTrust North America 877-528-7878

Auto Owners 800-252-4626


Bankers Insurance 800-765-9700

Berkshire Hathaway Guard 570-825-0611


Cabrillo / Safe Harbor Insurance 866-896-7233

Capitol Preferred Insurance 888-388-2742

CHUBB 800-252-4670

Citizens Property & Casualty 866-411-2742


Employers Insurance 888-682-6671


Florida Family 888-850-4663

Florida Peninsula 877-994-8368

Foremost Insurance (Auto Only) 800-274-7865


Geovera Insurance 877-448-5806

Great American Insurance 513-763-8505

Gulfstream Insurance 866-485-3005


Hagerty Insurance 800-922-4050

Hanover Insurance 800-628-0250

Hartford Insurance 800-243-5860

Heritage Insurance 855-415-7120


Liberty Mutual 800-225-2467

Lloyds of London

There is no central policy or claims number at Lloyd’s. In the event of a claim, policyholders should always follow the instructions set out in the insurance policy. The proper parties to be notified should be specified in the policy and they should be notified in accordance with the claims procedure of that policy.


Mendota Insurance 800-422-0793

Mercury Insurance 800-503-3724

Modern USA 866-270-8430


National General 800-325-1088


Old Dominion 866-270-8430

Olympus Insurance 866-281-2242


Prime Rate Finance 800-777-7458

Progressive Insurance 800-776-4737


RLI Corporation 800-444-0406


Safe Harbor / Cabrillo 866-896-7233

SAFECO 800-332-3226

Security First Insurance 877-581-4862

Southern Fidelity Insurance Company 866-722-4995

Southern Oak Insurance 877-900-2280

Summit Insurance Group 800-762-7811


TAPCO 800-334-5579

The Hartford 800-243-5860

Tower Hill 800-216-3711

Travelers Insurance 800-252-4633


Universal Property & Casualty 800-218-3206


Wright Flood Insurance 800-820-3242


Zenith Insurance 800-440-5020

Need to file a claim? Want to make a change to one of your policies? We’re here to serve you. Please call us at (850) 398-5810

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *